[Verse 1]

Watch your step on the threshold, the floorboards are loose, There's no electricity, kerosene, juice. Just towers of paper and tin cans and rust — A house buried twenty years deep in the dust. Nothing in the hallway, Boards across the stair, Every upper bedroom Nailed up tight and square…

[Verse 2]

There's a draft from the kitchen behind that screen door, And tracks in the frost going straight cross the floor. Sheriff, hold steady — my light's on the frame — The lock's hanging open… Stay back, Frank. Let me aim.

[Chorus]

Through the flashlight beam, in the freezing gloom, Every shadow shifts in the silent room! What a quiet man kept behind his gate, Out of sight and mind till it's far too late! Hold your breath and shine where the rafters lean — Nothing stays concealed in the flashlight beam!

[Bridge]

Sweet merciful heaven… Ma… oh, God, Ma… Get Frank to the cruiser! Don't let him look twice! Keep sweeping the corners — this place is cold ice! What is that on the table? What is that by the chair? Those aren't hunting trophies — there's bone everywhere! Box after box! Shelf after shelf! He dug up the graveyard And kept it himself!

[Chorus]

Through the flashlight beam, in the midnight cold, Every nightmare story a town ever told! All the Sunday neighbors who smiled at his face Never knew the monster inside of this place! Lock the doors behind us and radio the state — Plainfield's woke up to a terrible fate!

[Outro]

Call Madison. Bring the crime lab. And somebody keep me away from his cell.

Cover art for Through the Flashlight Beam, from Plainfield: A Midwestern Gothic Musical: vintage Broadway poster showing officers sweeping flashlights across a dark, cluttered farmhouse room toward a kneeling man, lettered PLAINFIELD with the song title.