[Verse 1]

You sat in that chair for sixteen straight hours, Denied every charge with your mild little manners! We found the remains in your kitchen and shed — Now tell me the truth, Ed, before I see red! Well, golly, Art, this pie is mighty fine, Your wife sure knows how to bake a crust in line. I didn't mean no fuss or county spree — You never asked the right way until three!

[Chorus]

It's just common sense, Sheriff, plain as the snow! When a fella needs parts, well, you go where they go! Why waste a good box when the cemetery's near, And nobody's using 'em half of the year? A little bit of mending, a little bit of glue — It's just common sense, Sheriff, wouldn't you?

[Verse 2]

You robbed forty graves in the middle of night?! You crafted a vest out of skin by lamplight?! You shot poor Bernice in her own hardware store And dragged her right out through the back alley door?! Now hold on a minute, let's get the facts straight: I only dug nine — and I locked every gate! And as for Bernice, well, the rifle went pop While I was just looking at shells in the shop! I never ate none of 'em — heaven forbid! My mother would tan me if ever I did!

[Bridge]

You read in the papers of islands afar, Where folks keep their kinfolk right under a jar. I missed my dear Ma, and I felt mighty blue, So I thought I'd make something familiar and new! A lampshade for reading, a belt for my waist — Everything tidy and nothing to waste! Lord help us, Ed… don't you feel any shame? Shame? Why, Sheriff, nobody's even to blame! I kept to myself and I paid all my tax, And I always returned every borrowed pickaxe!

[Chorus]

It's just common sense, Sheriff, plain as can be! A quiet home hobby for Mother and me! You stitch up the seams and you sweep up the floor, And nobody bothers you knocking your door! Now pass me the coffee, if that's all right with you — It's just common sense, Sheriff, through and through!

[Outro]

Lock him up… Send him to Waupun… Much obliged, Art!

Cover art for Just Common Sense, Sheriff, from Plainfield: A Midwestern Gothic Musical: vintage Broadway poster showing Eddie calmly eating pie at a table while the sheriff sits across from him with his head in his hand, lettered PLAINFIELD with the song title.